Podbean Podcast Site Category :   Gaming   Tags :              

The Noise Before Defeat

The Noise Before Defeat is a podcast about wargaming.

3
Jun 2010
Episode 10 WWII Tactical Wargames
Posted in Wargaming by thenoisebeforedefeat at 8:59 am

In this episode Colin and Paul discuss WWII Tactical Wargames, including Advanced Squad Leader, Advanced Tobruk System, Lock'n Load, Conflict of Heroes, Combat Commander, TCS, Panzer Grenadier and others. This episode also features Moritz Eggert, reviewing Combat Commander. There is also a new contest to win a copy of ATS Stalingrad Large Hex edition.

I'm going to post a separate thread for the competition. If you want to enter post there. If you post your entry here I'll still count it, but I'd rather separate them.

Links The Adventuring Party check out the Non Exp episodes they are the wargaming one http://theadventuringparty.libsyn.com/index.php?post_category=podcasts

I've Been Diced http://ivebeendiced.blogspot.com/

The Two Half Squads http://www.the2halfsquads.com/

Listen Now:


icon for podbean  Standard Podcasts: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download | Embeddable Player | Hits (2617)


You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response , or trackback from your own site.

Rate it:
(2 ratings)

16 Responses:

Richard Savage said:

OMG less blather about what constitutes a tactical game and more talk ABOUT them!


thenoisebeforedefeat said:

Well you will be happy to know it is about a 10minute segment in a 2 1/2 hour podcast, so you won’t have to endure too much.


Paul Glenn said:

Just a note–the first Lock ‘n Load game was “Forgotten Heroes,” which covered the Vietnam War.


thenoisebeforedefeat said:

Cheers Paul, I’m thinking of picking it up. I quite liked Lock ‘n Load and I’ve got a couple friends who like it too.


Paul Glenn said:

I haven’t played Forgotten Heroes; I have played Band of Heroes, which I like. But I’m primarily interested in operational and strategic level games.


Eric Walters said:

I know the podcast was pretty long, but someday I’d hope that you cover some of the variations in playing WWII Ground Tactical wargames, particularly ASL, ASLSK, ATS, and the “Heroes” series of LNL games–particularly double-blind umpired games using scenarios where neither player is sure of the opponent victory conditions or order of battle. Some of the best games I’ve ever played or umpired were of this genre….


thenoisebeforedefeat said:

That is an interesting thought Eric, it hadn’t occured to me to be honest. Umpired games can be pretty fun and I think it would be interesting. I would say for me personally we don’t have the community here to support that, at least in auckland, but it would be very cool.


Jay R. said:

I’ve never seen a tactical game that included elements of the operational - so I’m not sure why the podcasters would suggest it is hard to tell what is a tactical game and what isn’t. “Blather” is a good description, as the other commentor noted.

I have a hard time understanding the appeal of these 2-hour podcasts. There are a number of excellent websites that will define a “tactical wargame” in seconds if I just go and read them. You’re not offering anything new. A ten minute segment with some humour, or an interview with someone connected to the industry, would be of far more interest. Two or three unknowns sitting around gabbing to each other in an obviously unscripted environment is not giving me any value. Hobby time is scarce and precious - sorry, but I’d rather be playing a game than listening to this. You’re not entertaining and you’re not educating if all you’re doing is arguing with each other. Figure out what you want to say, and then say it - efficiently. Turn on a radio and start taking notes on what they’re doing.


Steven Alpert said:

.


Steven Alpert said:

Hey guys, I enjoyed your podcast on tactical wargames. I like your analytical style and I like the two hour length too, and I do look forward to TheNoiseB4Defeat. I have a topic suggestion for you: D-Day Games. I recently purchased three new games that all involve D-Day: “Liberty Roads” by Hexasim Games, “Normandy ‘44″ by Mark Simonitch/GMT Games, and “D-DAY Omaha Beach” by Decision Games, which is a solitaire game. All of these games are getting a lot of buzz and doing a topic devoted to D-Day games should prove interesting. You could also compare and contrast these new games with older D-Day games such as Breakout Normandy. What do you think?


thenoisebeforedefeat said:

I think that is a great idea Steven, I’ve only played Liberty Roads, but N44 looks quite good. I’m sure DDay at Omaha beach could be looked at too.


Gary Barr said:

Hi chaps

Just discovered your podcasts and enjoy them as background listening when painting up miniatures or settting up a board wargame. Keep up the good work.

Cheers From N.Ireland UK


Micah Plymire said:

I found your web site on another site. It contains wonderful and helpful posts. Its amazing to think one site could contain so muck information. You have something good going here, keep it up!


Jestine Gillom said:

It is about time someone wrote a good quality post on this topic


Alyse Ridolfi said:

Looking forward to your next article


free classifieds Singapore said:

and we are looking to…

Do you have a spam problem on this site; I also am a blogger, and I was wondering your situation; we have created some nice practices and we are looking to swap techniques with others, why not shoot me an email if interested….


Leave a Reply









Please enter the text from the image above: